How to deal with hard problems approximation algorithms. Outline 1 how to deal with hard problems 2 approximation algorithms 3 traveling salesman problem tsp 4tsp. Approximation algorithms for nphard problems lecture by dan suthers for university of hawaii information and computer sciences course 311 on algorithms. The first part of the book presents a set of classical np hard problems, set covering, bin packing, knapsack, etc. The approximation algorithms framework provides a guarantee on the quality of the solution obtained. These algorithms are extracted from a number of fundamental papers, which are of long, delicate presentations. Tight approximation algorithms for maximum general assignment. Module 6 p, np, npcomplete problems and approximation. Approximation algorithms for nphard clustering problems. Developing approximation algorithms for np hard problems is now a very active field in mathematical programming and theoretical computer science. Approximation algorithms for nphard p roblems 1477 f or a given list of supplies r r 1. For all of the above problems, our results improve on the best previous approximation algorithms or schemes, which are.
Probabilistic checking of proofs and the hardness of approximation problems. Approximation algorithms for nphard problems acm sigact. Reduction from the set partition, an npcomplete problem. Instead, we can focus on design approximation algorithm. For many npcomplete problems there are approximation algorithms that are fast and give an answer that is close to the optimal e. Pdf the design of approximation algorithms download full. In the last 25 years there have been several approximation algorithms proposed for np hard problems. Approximation algorithms for regretbounded vehicle. Pdf approximation algorithms for npproblems deepak. Coffman and others published approximation algorithms for nphard problems find, read and cite all the research you need on researchgate. Algorithms for facility location problems with outliers. Maxcut, max2sat pdf a really good survey by helmberg on the techniques for solving sdp and its applications to nphard optimization problems.
Approximation algorithms for np hard problems part ii lecturer. Approximation algorithms many of the npcomplete problems are. Introduction to approximation algorithms many important computational problems are di. An algorithm for a maximization problem is called a. The general form of the tsp appears to have been first studied by mathematicians during the 1930s in vienna and at harvard, notably by karl. A randomized constantfactor approximation algorithm for the kmedian problem that runs in. Approximation algorithms will be the focus of this course. Following are some npcomplete problems, for which no polynomial time algorithm is known. We undertake a systematic study of regretrelated vehiclerouting problems from the perspective of approximation algorithms. In computer science and operations research, approximation algorithms are efficient algorithms that find approximate solutions to optimization problems in particular nphard problems with provable guarantees on the distance of the returned solution to the optimal one. Introduction elementary fundamentals deterministic approaches.
No approximation algorithm having a guarantee of 32. Approximation algorithms for nphard clustering problems ramgopal r. An introduction to the methods of designing algorithms for hard computing tasks, concentrating mainly on approximate, randomized, and heuristic algorithms, and. The class p consists of all polynomialtime solvable decision problems.
Approximation algorithms for np hard problems is intended for computer scientists and operations researchers interested in specific algorithm implementations, as well as design tools for algorithms. Beating 2epsilon has been related to some other open problems it is unique games hard, but is not known to be. Numerous practical problems are integer optimization problems that are intractable. We can replace the nondeterministic guessing of stage 1 with the deterministic algorithm for the decision problem, and then in stage 2. In the 1990s, parallel developments in techniques for designing approximation algorithms as well as methods for proving hardness of approximation results have led to a beautiful theory. Such problems are commonly addressed with heuristics that provide a solution, but not information on the solutions quality. Algorithmics for hard problems electronic resource. The travelling salesman problem was mathematically formulated in the 1800s by the irish mathematician w.
This book is actually a collection of survey articles written by some of the foremost experts in this field. Williamson school of operations research and information engineering cornell university february 28, 2011 university of bonn bonn, germany david p. This covers bothmaximizationandminimizationproblems. Pdf approximation algorithms for npproblems deepak garg. Hamilton and by the british mathematician thomas kirkman. Approximation algorithms have developed in response to the impossibility of solving a great variety of important optimization problems. Klein department of computer science brown university neal e.
In the worstcase paradigm, algorithms for nphard problems are typically characterized by their approximation ratio, defined as the ratio between the worstcase cost of the algorithm and the cost of an allpowerful optimal algorithm. Williamson cornell university open problems bonn 1 54. All have their merits, but also their limitations, and need a large body of theory as their basis. Approximation algorithms for nphard problems part ii lecturer. Algorithmic design, especially for hard problems, is more essential for success in solving them than any standard improvement of current computer technologies. All of these optimization problems are nphard, and polynomial time approximation algorithms havebeenstudiedsee17,4,5,6,31,19,15,21,23.
Now, let us consider an approximation algorithm for nphard problem, vertex cover. Nphard problems 5 equations dix ci, i 1,2,n, we obtain a representation of x through cis. Introduction to combinatorial optimization, randomization, approximation, and heuristics author. In this chapter we introduce the important concept of approximation algorithms. Introduction to combinatorial optimization, randomization, approximation, and heuristics. Npcompleteness, various heuristics, as well as quantum algorithms, perhaps the most advanced and modern topic. In the remaining chapters we shall indicate some strategies to cope with nphard combinatorial optimization problems. The christofides algorithm was one of the first approximation algorithms, and was in part responsible for drawing attention to approximation algorithms as a practical approach to intractable problems. Pdf approximation algorithms for nphard optimization. We give a few examples of approximation algorithms for nphard combinatorial optimization problems below. Approximation algorithms for nphard problems lecture by dan suthers for university of hawaii information and computer sciences course 311 on. We have taken several particular perspectives in writing the book. A signi cant shortcoming of these simple formulations is that a few very distant clients, called outliers, can exert a disproportionately strong in. Module 6 p, np, npcomplete problems and approximation algorithms.
Subexponential algorithms for unique games and related problems. Unfortunately many of the combinatorial problems that arise in a computational context are np hard, so that optimal solutions are unlikely to be found in. Strategies to cope with npcomplete problems we will call these approximation algorithms. Have a variable xi for each vertex with constraint 0.
Approximation algorithms an overview sciencedirect topics. Approximation algorithms for nphard problems is intended for computer scientists and operations researchers interested in specific algorithm implementations, as well as design tools for algorithms. Mettu 103014 3 measuring cluster quality the cost of a set of cluster centers is the sum, over all points, of the weighted distance from each point to the. Approximation algorithms for nphard optimization problems. A signi cant shortcoming of these simple formulations is that a few very distant clients, called outliers, can exert a. Pcomplete approximation problems ucsb computer science. There are several approaches to attack hard problems. Determining whether a boolean formula is satisfiable, etc. Some of these algorithms are useable in the real world. Approximation algorithms for nphard problems edited by dorit s. Admit a preferably constant approximation algorithm in fpt time.
Both versions of are apx hard via simple reductions from tspand path theorem 7. Klein p and young n approximation algorithms for nphard optimization problems algorithms and theory of computation handbook, 3434 misra n, narayanaswamy n, raman v and shankar b solving minones2sat as fast as vertex cover proceedings of the 35th international conference on mathematical foundations of computer science, 549555. Too frequently, when attempting to get a solution for a problem, one is confronted with the fact that the problem is nphard. Here is now another 2approximation algorithm for vertex cover. Limits of approximation algorithms 2 feb, 2010 imsc. Note that in step 2, if the outcome of checking is no, then we cannot give any conclusion and hence nondeterministic computation stucks. Approximation algorithms for npcomplete problems on. Approximation algorithms for nphard optimization problems philip n. Recent work in the analysis of randomized approximation algorithms for nphard optimization problems has involved approximating the solution to a problem by the solution of a related subproblem of constant size, where the subproblem is constructed by sampling elements of the original problem uniformly at random. Juraj hromkovic published by springer berlin heidelberg isbn. In fact, many of those problems are nphard1, which means that no polynomialtime algorithm exists that solves the problem optimally unless pnp. Vazirami presented the problems and solutions in a unified framework. Approximation algorithms for nphard problems part ii. Limits of approximation algorithms 28 jan, 2010 tifr lec.
Think of xi 1 as picking the vertex, and xi 0 as not picking it, and inbetween as partially picking it. Pdf algorithmics for hard problems introduction to. W1hard problems with fpt time approximation algorithms. Chapter design techniques for approximation algorithms. Most combinatorial optimization problems are nphard to solve optimally.
Ajesh babu we will continue the survey of approximation algorithms in this lecture. A problem with this approach is that very few problems are susceptible to such techniques and for most nphard problems the best algorithm we know runs in truly. In the case of nphard problems, we sacrifice optimality in the favor of efficient heuristics that give nearlyoptimal approximate solutions, and aim for provable guarantees on the performance of these. As a matter of fact, the term algorithm was not commonly extended to approximation algorithms until later. A natural approach to cope with this intractability is to design an approximation. We also prove the existence of cycles of best response moves, and exponentially long bestresponse paths to pure or sink equilibria. In some cases, an approximation algorithm is a useful heuristic for finding. Approximation algorithm book the design of approximation. Approximation algorithm c hu ding michigan state university cse 331 algorithm and data structures 1 16. Np hard problems vary greatly in their approximability. The field of approximation algorithms has developed in response to the difficulty in solving a good many optimization problems exactly. Approximation algorithms for nphard problems dorit. Klein p and young n approximation algorithms for np hard optimization problems algorithms and theory of computation handbook, 3434 misra n, narayanaswamy n, raman v and shankar b solving minones2sat as fast as vertex cover proceedings of the 35th international conference on mathematical foundations of computer science, 549555. Lecture notes on approximation algorithms volume i stanford.
P, npproblems class np nondeterministic polynomial is the class of decision problems that can be solved by nondeterministic polynomial algorithms. Approximation algorithms for np hard optimization problems philip n. Approximation algorithms for regretbounded vehicle routing. Note that the determinant of any submatrix of at,it equals to the determinant of a submatrix of a. Coffman and others published approximation algorithms for nphard problems find, read and cite all the research you need on. Because of this, the design of algorithms for solving hard problems is the core of current algorithmic research from the theoretical point. With chapters contributed by leading researchers in the field, this book introduces unifying techniques in the analysis of approximation algorithms. That is, pesudoapproximation algorithms for capacitated kfacility location problems may be extended to get approximation algorithms for wellstudied capacitated facility location problems. Suppose we are given an npcomplete problem to solve. The nal part iv is about ways of dealing with hard problems. The last two decades has witnessed tremendous developments in the design of approximation algorithms mostly fueled by convex optimization techniques such as. Im looking for problems that are hard to solve in fpt time but has an approximation algorithm. However, a nondeterministic algorithm is considered to solve a decision problem correctly if there exists a guessed result leading to correct yesanswer.
Tu eindhoven advanced algorithms 2il45 course notes lecture 5. Approximation algorithms for hard capacitated location problems. So far we have dealt mostly with polynomially solvable problems. Finally, we study naturally dened gametheoretic versions of these problems, and show that they have price of anarchy of 2. Some open problems in approximation algorithms david p. As we illustrate below, additivervrp turns out to be the more fundamen. Unfortunately, the proposed algorithms are problem specific. Approximation algorithms for nphard problems guide books. Approximation algorithms naturally arise in the field of theoretical computer science as a consequence of the widely believed.
The need to solve truly large instances of computationally hard problems, such as those arising from the internet or the human genome project, has also. Sampling subproblems of heterogeneous maxcut problems. Approximation algorithms for nphard problems acm sigact news. They deal with various aspects of the complexity of finite automata, the information content of online problems, stability of approximation algorithms, reoptimization algorithms, computer science education, and many other topics within the fields of algorithmics and complexity theory. Approximation algorithms for hard capacitated location. Determining whether a graph has a hamiltonian cycle. Both versions of are apxhard via simple reductions from tspand path theorem 7. Tight approximation algorithms for maximum general. In approximation algorithms for nphard problems, dorit hochbaum.
Approximating nphard problems efficient algorithms and their limits. Too frequently, when attempting to get a solution for a problem, one is confronted with the fact that the problem is np hard. Here approximation algorithms must be mentioned in the first place. Algorithms are at the heart of problem solving in scientific computing and computer science. Unfortunately many of the combinatorial problems that arise in a computational context are nphard, so that optimal solutions are unlikely to be found in.
1057 128 715 1047 1343 1192 193 1268 329 468 23 631 409 973 297 1245 1318 249 843 837 679 1448 1038 741 235 1051 770 1481 7 983 852 1435 1007