Jul 11, 2008 ruby s open classes are powerful but can easily be misused. This is useful when the methodsvariables of an instance are based on a data file that isnt available until runtime. Ruby journal howtoopenslashoverrideslash monkey patch aclassin ruby. Monkeypatching a python instance method par alex marandon publie 09112016 for a django project, i needed an easy way to automatically add a specific query string parameter named token to any url. So you search for how to moneykey patch a class in ruby. Im taking the ruby standard library class numeric parent of all number based classes in ruby such as integer and float, opening it back up and. That means, it is making changes to a module or class while the program is running. Rubys almost pure objectorientedness, concise syntax and praising of method chains often make us to want even more concise and readable. In ruby, you can define a class and later redefine it and of course, you can modify individual instances of a class so that. Therefore, a monkey patch might break code which doesnt expect the extended behavior, and multiple monkey patches for the same class might cause conflicts. Note that patching the method for just one instance is currently not possible, patchinstancemethod will patch it for all instances. Oneoff monkey patching to add logging can also be very useful. The two methods above require changing the system to avoid monkey patching. Other forms of modifying classes at runtime have different names.
Examples are security fixes by security specialists when an official patch by. Monkeypatching is destroying ruby the title of this post is intended to be deliberately provocative, as well as being a nod to steven colberts the people destroying america segments. Apr 18, 2008 with that in mind, i was playing around with some ironruby interop with the clr recently. In ruby land, monkey patching is the act of modifying the methods on someone elses class. Object inherits from basicobject which allows creating alternate object hierarchies. In this situation, i need to accomplish two things. How do you know if an object is an instance of a class. Prepend and super for elegant monkey patching sebastian royer. This practice, known as monkey patching, is common in the ruby. An unofficial patch is a noncommercial patch for a commercial software created by a third party instead of the original developer. Here are some good explanations at this stackoverflow thread, and citing patrick ewing well, i was just totally sold by adam, the idea being that if it walks like a duck and talks like a duck, its a. Before i show you how to override a class, i want to ensure that you understand that monkeypatching.
Ruby language monkey patching in ruby ruby tutorial. Before i show you how to override a class, i want to ensure that you understand that monkey patching is not considered a good practice. All users of the monkeypatched class see the same changes. Ruby implements the class hierarchy by instantiating class objects, so there is a second instance at play here. In order to patch a method your patches need to follow the following principles when defining them.
But when you attach methods to an object that just plain fail when you call them. Due to rubys open classes you can redefine or add functionality to existing classes. Monkey patching a monkey patch is a way for a program to extend or modify supporting system software locally affecting only the running instance of the program. Jun 17, 2015 ruby has a very beautiful syntax and so it can be tempting to monkey patch a class to turn some ugly method call into something that is more readable.
Rubygems patches remote code execution vulnerability. Whats the deal with monkeypatching and why is everyone. Because ruby is an interpreted language objects are open and can be modified at runtime. Make monkey patching in ruby less risky with refinements. Its simply the dynamic replacement of attributes at runtime. I was surprised that this didnt work, but i soon realized that in this instance, were not opening string, were defining battleboatsstring. Were in the future, and with github and bundler there is now rarely a need to monkey patch ruby code in your applications monkey patching is the dangerousyetfrequentlyuseful technique of reopening existing classes to change or add to their behavior. However, in the class scope inside the class, but outside of any methods, the scope is the class instance scope. Monkey patching is the practice of adding methods to or altering ruby s core classes. Why rubys monkey patching is better than land mines. In ruby, the term monkey patch means any dynamic modification to a class. How to monkey patch a class in ruby solid foundation web. Say i am monkey patching a method in a class, how could i call the overridden method from the overriding method. When you monkey patch core classes, you add to the core ruby apis.
This is admittedly not a very useful monkey patch, but it demonstrates that we can reach into any class, including core classes like array, and modify it on the fly. This just makes your monkey patches much more surefire. It is not a standard technique for software development. I was about to correct your use of the term monkey patch thinking it applied only to modifications of ruby s builtin methodsbut after googling it appears there is no consensus as to its meaning. So you search for how to moneykeypatch a class in ruby. In ruby, the term monkey patch was misunderstood to mean any dynamic modification to a class and is often used as a synonym for dynamically modifying any class at runtime. It is a vague term, the best definition is dynamic modification of a class on runtime, and in this case specifically it is redefining an instance method on runtime. Even though the ruby community as a whole has been slow to adopt this method, its worth working into your own code when you find yourself wanting to monkeypatch an existing class. Interfaces are statically checked python duck typing. Hal fulton gives an example of creating an oo csv parser at an exercise in metaprogramming with ruby. Similar to an ordinary patch, it alleviates bugs or shortcomings. Monkey patching, while convenient, has some pitfalls that arent immediately obvious. But nonetheless, the ability to monkey patch any class is extremely powerful.
Why ruby s monkey patching is better than land mines. It shouldnt be that big of a leap to realize that we shouldnt monkey patch our own objects either, and for the same reasons, because its better when. The trick is to save and use the existing method as we did above, and then bind the new function to the instance with types. Lets create a hypothetical scenario in which i need to monkey patch the hash class. Every instance created from a class adheres to that class. Writing dsls in ruby without monkeypatching object. Its more okay for an application to monkey patch than a gem, for instance. In ruby, a monkey patch mp is any dynamic modification to a class and is often used as a synonym for dynamically modifying any class add new or overwrite existing. A monkeypatch is a piece of programming code which extends or modifies other code at runtime.
Take the example below where i am implementing a simplified version of a monkey patch that rails does. Nov 20, 2015 the monkey patch refers to the ability for ruby to dynamically define and override methods on existing classes and modules at runtime. Each prefix and postfix can get all the parameters of the original method as well as the instance if original method is not static and the return value. Dec 29, 2017 monkeypatching this way allows you to opt into custom behavior without having it leak out into other parts of your application. This resource contains a collection of ruby best practices and ruby tips provided by our toptal network members. Its provocative because i want to get people talking about this issue. Ruby is like a sharp knife, it can be extremely effective, but its usually your own fault if you cut yourself. And by their nature, bugs caused by monkey patches are more difficult to track down than those introduced by more traditional classes and methods. Monkey patching this way allows you to opt into custom behavior without having it leak out into other parts of your application. To solve these problems, refinements provide a way to extend classes locally. Monkey patching is the new black in the ruby community.
Unpatchinstancemethod, will undo patchinstancemethod. We can convert this to a monkey patch and test it out. Demonstrate how to dynamically add variables to an object a class instance at runtime. How to properly monkeypatch a ruby class in ruby on rails. When monkey patching an instance method, can you call the overridden method from the new implementation. There are many cases where its fine to monkey patch, but it should definitely not be your first weapon of choice. Monkey patch method on single object stack overflow. Methods on object are available to all classes unless explicitly overridden. What if, for example, you decide to monkey patch ruby s string class to produce a quickfix that shortens a certain section of code in your program.
In this example ive reopened the string core class and added a lipsum class method understanding class methods verses instance methods in. Im actually really surprised go doesnt just let you add methods to arbitrary types that you dont own. Object mixes in the kernel module, making the builtin kernel functions globally accessible. Since the test mock doesnt monkey patch the class its mocking, the. General monkey patching in java, classes are defined up front, compiled into bytecode, and remain unaltered. This is a community driven project, so you are encouraged to. If you want to remove all currently applied monkeypatches simply call monkey. Other forms of modifying classes at runtime have different names, based on their different intents. The definition of the term varies depending upon the community using it.
Add a variable to a class instance at runtime rosetta code. As such, this page will be updated on a regular basis to include additional information and cover emerging ruby techniques. Some more searching finds this ruby issue from 2015, which helpfully includes a patch. This section shows the preferred and least invasive method of monkey patching, should changing the system not be an option. Refinementsspec ruby master ruby issue tracking system. Monkey patch method on single object rubyonrails ruby monkeypatching. Monkeypatching a python instance method makina corpus. Even though the ruby community as a whole has been slow to adopt this method, its worth working into your own code when you find yourself wanting to monkey patch an existing class. Before i show you how to override a class, i want to ensure that you understand that monkeypatching is not considered a good practice. In ruby, python, and many other dynamic programming languages, the term monkey patch only refers to dynamic modifications of a class or module at runtime, motivated by the intent to patch existing thirdparty code as a workaround to a bug or feature which does not act as desired.
Ruby s open classes are powerful but can easily be misused. Monkey patch on rails validators pablo marti medium. Unfortunately many times developers monkey patch object to reach their goal, to make this methods available. Until you hit weird bugs because a patch changed hash. Monkey patching is a powerful tool in the ruby ecosystem but wield it sparingly especially if you are going to jumble into code that does not belong to you. To the point that smart, experienced hackers reach for a monkey patch as their tool of first resort, even when a simpler, more traditional solution is possible. The above statement asserts that the ruby usage is incorrect but terms evolve, and thats not always a bad thing. Monkey patch ruby on rails cookie based session store to use. In early 2002, the englishlanguage ruby talk mailing list was receiving more messages than the japaneselanguage ruby list, demonstrating ruby s increasing popularity in the nonjapanese speaking world. Ruby makes it easy to add, remove, and replace methods on any class even core classes like array but it is generally frowned upon.
This article looks at how to minimize the risk of opening classes, alternatives, and how other languages provide similar capabilities. You can read the definition in the wikipedia link i provided, but in short, it is a way to modify the behavior of a class or instance of a class at runtime without changing the source of that class or instance. Safer monkey patching in ruby thomas countz medium. Or perhaps you need to monkey patch a class you own.
Youre adding a potential maintenance problem tight coupling and compatibility issue, and you need to weigh the risks and benefits. This can cause unintended sideeffects or breakage of programs. Refinements due to rubys open classes you can redefine or add functionality to existing classes. It is often used when monkey patching an existing method to tailor its functionality to the.
712 1057 1027 675 108 1047 1393 806 390 903 1326 908 1537 1445 1159 845 292 1306 1459 414 1354 837 1303 485 1219 900 488 23 177 83 1273 1014